E-commerce

Shopify vs Amazon: where should a brand sell first?

Shopify vs Amazon for brands: what each sale costs, where buyers come from, who owns the customer, and which one to start on.

By Errika DeVall7 min read

Halftone collage illustration of a hand holding a key ring with two different keys, an old skeleton key and a modern flat key

You have one product line and one budget, and the Shopify vs Amazon decision sets where both go first. We are Riithink, a digital marketing agency that builds Shopify stores and runs Amazon accounts for e-commerce brands.

This post compares the two on what a sale costs, where the buyers come from and who keeps the customer afterward. It ends with which one to start on and how to run both.

The short version

What is the difference between Shopify and Amazon?

Shopify is software for running your own online store on your own domain. Amazon is a marketplace where your product sits on a shared page next to competing offers. That one difference drives the rest of the comparison:

ShopifyAmazon
What you getYour own store and checkoutA listing in Amazon's store
Monthly cost$39 on Basic, billed monthly$39.99 on the Professional plan
Fee on each saleCard processing, 2.9% + 30¢ on BasicReferral fee, 8% to 15% in most categories
Where buyers come fromTraffic you bringShoppers already searching Amazon
Customer contactYou keep the email and can market to itOrder and service messages only
ShippingYou, a warehouse partner, or AmazonYou, or Fulfillment by Amazon

Prices are from each company's US pricing page in November 2026.

Shopify vs Amazon fees: what one sale costs

Shopify takes a small cut of each sale and Amazon takes a larger one. The monthly fees are almost the same, so the fee on each order decides the comparison.

Shopify's plans cost $39, $105 and $399 a month when billed monthly, and less when billed yearly. Card processing through Shopify falls from 2.9% + 30¢ on the Basic plan to 2.5% + 30¢ on Advanced. When you use Shopify's own payments, that is the only fee on the sale.

On Amazon, the Professional selling plan is $39.99 a month, plus a referral fee on every item sold. The referral fee is a percentage of the price that depends on the category, with a 30¢ minimum in most categories. Home and kitchen is 15%. Consumer electronics is 8%. Clothing priced above $20 is 17%.

Take one $40 home and kitchen product:

Shopify (Basic)Amazon (Professional)
Fee on the order$1.46 (2.9% + 30¢)$6.00 (15%)
What you keep before shipping and ads$38.54$34.00

$4.54more in fees per order on Amazon than on Shopify, for a $40 home and kitchen product. Shopify and Amazon US pricing, November 2026

The difference is $4.54 an order. On Amazon, that money buys a place in front of people who are already shopping. On Shopify, you keep it, and you spend it on the ads, search work or email that bring a buyer to the store. If a new customer costs you more than $4.54 to win on your own site, Amazon is the cheaper channel for that first order. The second order is where a Shopify store pulls ahead, because you can email the buyer for free.

Where do the buyers come from?

Amazon brings the shoppers and Shopify does not. In Feedvisor's 2026 survey of 1,006 US consumers, 62% named Amazon as the place their product search starts, and 74% named it when they are ready to buy. The search figure was 80% a year earlier, so shoppers are spreading out. More than half of them still begin on Amazon.

62%of US shoppers start their product search on Amazon. Feedvisor, 2026 survey of 1,006 US consumers

Independent sellers make most of those sales. They accounted for 61% of the paid units sold in Amazon's stores worldwide in the third quarter of 2026.

A new Shopify store starts with no visitors. Every one arrives through something you pay for or build: search ads, social ads, search rankings, creators, or an email list. That takes a budget and a few months. Building the store itself is the fast part, and it is what our Shopify development service covers.

Halftone collage illustration of a hand pushing the arm of an old metal turnstile.

Who owns the customer?

On Shopify, you do. On Amazon, Amazon does.

Amazon lets a seller contact a buyer only to complete an order or answer a customer service question. Its Communication Guidelines state that you cannot contact buyers for marketing or promotional purposes, whether by email, mail or phone. A buyer who loved the product hears from you again only if they search for you or see your ad.

A Shopify store creates a customer profile when someone signs up, places an order or abandons a checkout. The profile holds the email address, the order history and the customer's marketing preferences. You can email one customer or a whole group of them, such as everyone who bought once and never came back.

That list is what makes a second sale cheap. It also belongs to you if a platform changes its fees or rules.

Shopify vs Amazon FBA: who ships the order?

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) means you send stock to Amazon's warehouses and Amazon stores it, packs and ships each order, and handles customer service and returns. You pay a fulfillment fee on each unit, based on the product's price, weight and dimensions. Storage is charged monthly by the cubic foot, and stock that sits for more than 181 days costs extra.

Shopify does not ship anything. You pack orders yourself or hire a warehouse partner, and you set the delivery promise and the packaging.

The two can share one warehouse. Amazon's own MCF and Buy with Prime app for Shopify fulfills your store's orders from the stock you already hold at Amazon. In the US, it can also offer Prime delivery on your store while you keep your own checkout. A brand that sells on both can hold one pool of inventory.

Is it better to sell on Amazon or Shopify first?

Start on the channel where your first customers already are.

Start on Amazon when:

  • people search for your kind of product by what it does, and nobody knows your brand name yet;
  • the product is easy to judge from photos, a price and reviews;
  • you have no audience and a small budget for ads outside Amazon.

Start on Shopify when:

  • you already have an audience, such as an email list, a social following or wholesale customers;
  • the product needs explaining, fitting or customizing before someone buys;
  • repeat orders or subscriptions are most of the plan, so the customer list is the asset;
  • your margin cannot carry a 15% referral fee.

Most brands with a product people search for end up on both. Amazon finds the buyers who were never going to visit your site. Your store serves the ones who look you up by name, and it keeps their details.

How to sell on Shopify and Amazon together

Run the two channels as one business with two reports.

Halftone collage illustration of a vintage tandem bicycle with two seats, seen from the side.
  1. Keep one count of stock. Shopify's Marketplace Connect app syncs listings, orders and inventory between your store and Amazon. The first 50 synced orders a month are free. After that the fee is 1% of each order, capped at $99 a month.
  2. Keep prices in line. Amazon shows sellers a competitive external price for each product and advises pricing at or below it. An offer priced too high can lose the Featured Offer, the offer shown with the Add to Cart button on a product page. Raising the Amazon price to cover the referral fee can cost you that spot. If other sellers are undercutting you, see our post on MAP enforcement.
  3. Claim the bonus for traffic you send. Amazon's Brand Referral Bonus pays US brand owners an average of 10% of the sales their own marketing sends to Amazon. It arrives about two months after the sale. If a social ad works better pointed at your Amazon listing than at your store, the bonus gives back part of the referral fee.
  4. Report each channel on its own numbers. Give the store and the marketplace separate sales, ad spend and profit lines, so a good month on one cannot hide a bad month on the other. On the Amazon side, compare ad spend with total sales, which our post on ACoS vs TACoS explains.

If nobody in-house has time to run the marketplace side, that is the work our Amazon agency service does.

Next step

If you are weighing the two for a product line, tell us about your business and we will go through the numbers with you. If Amazon is already working and you want a second marketplace, read our guide to Walmart Marketplace for brands.

Share
Ask AI about this article

Questions people ask

Is the Amazon Individual plan enough for a brand?

Only for a test. The Individual plan has no monthly fee and costs 99¢ for each item sold, on top of the referral fee. Above 40 sales a month, the $39.99 Professional plan costs less.

What does it cost to offer Prime delivery on a Shopify store?

The app is free to install. Buy with Prime orders carry a Prime service fee of 3% of the order value, with a 30¢ minimum, and a fulfillment fee that starts at $5.60 a unit. Storage is billed separately. Check the current rate card before you price a product around it.

Can you move Amazon reviews to a Shopify store?

No. Shopify's free migration app imports your products from Amazon. It does not bring customers, orders or reviews. Plan to collect new reviews on your own site from your first orders.

Do you need a trademark to sell on Amazon?

You can list and sell without one. You need a pending or registered trademark to join Amazon Brand Registry, which is free. Brand Registry opens the tools a brand relies on, including richer product pages, a brand storefront and search data.

Written by

Errika DeVall

I have worked with C-level executives in various industries to develop sophisticated and strategic marketing initiatives with a high-level focus on digital.

She writes for Riithink, a digital marketing agency in Pittsboro, North Carolina, running e-commerce and paid media for brands that sell online. See what we do.

Want marketing in black and white?

Get a free audit

Want marketing in black and white?

Send us your store or your ad account. We'll send back a free marketing audit that says what's working, what isn't and what we'd do first.

© 2026 Riithink120 Mosaic Blvd, Suite 200-11, Pittsboro, NC 27312Google Partner · Amazon Ads Verified Partner